I'm pretty sure that an Indian tech worker's choices aren't rice paddies or Google. Pretty sure it is Google in the US or Microsoft in India. Likely at a lower rate, but we aren't taking Indian college graduates out of menial jobs and giving them high end tech work. That is absurd.
Although not H1B holders supposedly screwing educated American workers out of their jobs what's your opinion on Trump hiring foreign seasonal workers to fill positions at Mar-a-Lago and his other businesses in effect screwing lower skilled unemployed Americans out of jobs? As Trump pursues mass deportation, his businesses again seek foreign workers Trump vows to ‘hire American.’ His businesses keep hiring foreign guest workers
There is a little better argument for that but I would want to see the actual data. My hunch is there would be enough Americans willing to do a lot of those jobs. Maybe working picking fruit and vegetables and things like that could justify enough Americans wont do it.