Just to confirm, she is accusing Porter of punching her in the eye? One of the wives also accused him of "emotional abuse", but I can't find any examples of what was said or what she considers emotional abuse. I read the EPO. Seems they had an argument and he refused to leave her apartment until she threatened to call the police. Apparently they have been separated and had a Private Separation Agreement" or whatever that is and he was in some sort of violation. He left, but came back the next day. Apparently she had given him keys to the place and he could let himself in. She then slapped a restraining order on his ass. Hate to say it, but this isn't all that unusual. Ugly, but not unusual. They were subsequently divorced as how these things generally end. Now, I have no time for men who hit women, so if he smacked her, he is a total bitch and not allowed to date my daughter. I would encourage his ex-wife to press charges. But she did one thing better - she ruined his life.