My list is exciting in the beginning and pretty boring towards the end but here it goes...
#1970 1/2 Ford Falcon (looked just like a Torino)
#1971 Mustang Mach I Fastback
#1974 Mercury Comet
#1971 Torino GT
#1970 Torino Cobra 429
#1969 Olds Tornado
#1968 Caddy Coupe de Ville
#1978 Ford F-150
1984 Toyota Celica GT
1986 Ford Bronco II
1987 Toyota Tercel
1989 Ford Bronco II
1994 Honda Accord LX
1994 Honda Civic LX
1999 Honda CRV
1999 Honda Passport EX
* 2001 Honda CRV Limited Edition
* 2010 Honda Accord LX
* 2012 Honda Fit
# is before I got married.
* Still own.
Obviously I now like Hondas. I can honestly say in 18 years I have not yet had a single major issue save one and that was my favorite vehicle of all the ones I have owned which was the 1999 Honda Passport 4x4 EX. I loved this truck. It was great inside, drove well with no roll at all and it looked awesome. The only problem was the transmission started to go with only 50K on it and coincidentally the first gas crunch hit so I traded it for my '01 CRV. The kicker is the Passport wasn't made by Honda. It was a re-badged Isuzu Rodeo.
The Toronado and the Caddy were both special deals from a buddy of mine during some "lean" times. Neither was my cup of tea but the price was right. My wife and I did buy matching Bronco II's and I still hang my head in shame except I bought mine first. After we bought hers (and keeping in mind this was pre-Internet) I read about Bronco II rollovers. Not good.

I really liked that Toyota Celica. I have fond memories of both the Torino GT models I have owned but both (like my Mach I) had engine issues inherited from previous owners.
On my radar right now as my middle age crazy car (I'm not into motorcycles since I laid one down on the Garden State Parkway in NJ in the early 80's ; ) is the Dodge Challenger. I loved them back in the day (remember the movie "Vanishing Point"? ; ) and I love the way they still retained the look from back then. I have to be fair though. I like our current Accord and Fit. They are both spacious (the Fit looks small but inside it's very roomy), they both get great gas mileage and they both look real good.