GatorCountry.com Swamp Gas Forums - View Single Post - Peyton Manning punt protection and H-Back
View Single Post
Old 01-14-2013, 10:07 AM   #73
GatorLaw
Gator Country Silver
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 12,358
GatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond repute
GatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond reputeGatorLaw has a reputation beyond repute
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by rican35 View Post
fair shot? three yrs in the NFL is more than enough.. if it wasnt because of his popularity and his legions of fans he wouldve been out of the league already
Oh come on, "three yrs in the NFL is more than enough" is ridiculous. He sat on the bench most of his first year, part of his second, and all of his third. He's had the equivalent of only one full season as a starting QB and even that has been spread over three years with two different teams. Not exactly "more than enough" to judge what he might do if a team committed to him as their starting QB from day one and designed an offense that took advantage of his abilities.

I will say that I'm by no means sure that TT could be a good QB even if that were done. I look at QBs who have games similar to TT in terms of being dual threats, e.g. Russell Wilson and Colin Kaepernik (sp?), and it's obvious they're far better passing QBs than TT was with the Broncos. However, I don't think TT can be dismissed on the ground that his three years in the NFL has been "more than enough" to judge him.
__________________
Before you criticize someone walk a mile in their shoes. That way when you do criticize them you'll be a mile away and you'll have their shoes.
GatorLaw is offline   Reply With Quote