[GatorAvatar]

Originally Posted by Matthanuf06

Agree.

The star system is fine, and the results speak for themselves. 5 star players on average have better careers than 4 stars. 4 stars on average have better careers than 3 stars, and down the line.

Perhaps people would be better off thinking of this in terms of probability. The more stars, the more likely the player will be good. The player can still suck. The less stars, the less likely the player will be good. But the player still can be good.

Smartest post I've read on this board in a while.